Cellars Wine Club Review

90+ Point Wine Club Review


All-Around Wine Club Rating: 3.45


Wine ratings are subjective but it's rare to find a 90+ point wine that isn't of a certain respectable level of quality, even if you don't like it's taste.

What We Like

This 90+ point club is a little expensive if all you got were 90-point wines, but you really do get 90+ (usually +)!


We'd like a better understanding of how they select their wines. We know some of what they've selected, but not anything about why.

Cellars Wine Clubs sells their 90 Plus Point Wine Club as the ideal wine club for someone who “lives” wine. That hyperbole doesn’t pass muster for us... as there are some AMAZING wine clubs out there at steep prices that couldn’t even compare with this one. We also struggle with the notion of a 90+ wine club because wine ratings are so not scientific. However, we fully support a wine club dedicated to the cream of the crop of limited availability wines from around the world at outstanding value pricing of just $25 per bottle. Can you find 90-point wines for less than that? Sure. But to us, 90 points doesn’t equal a good wine or even a good deal. Despite the fact that we disagree with their marketing approach for this club, we trust Cellars to find 90-point wines that are both great and offering great value.

Cellars Wine Club offers a great deal of flexibility for when to start shipping and how often to ship.

Cellars offers a printable gift card for those last-minute gift purchases. We don’t want to judge a wine club buy it’s printable gift message, but the truth is, this one doesn’t really add anything to our opinion of the wine club.

The good news is, they have a great e-card offering. You can customize several aspects of this e-card to make it reflect your tastes. Again, we’re not judging the wine club based on it’s gift email offering... just letting you know they have one.

Last Updated: 10/3/2010

Jessyca Frederick

Things to know

  • Shipping is included
  • Shipping is Free to a Business Address, and $2 to Residential Addresses
  • Green / Eco-friendly Packaging

More wine clubs from Cellars Wine Club

Hey there! You are welcome to add your own feedback.
This comment feed is moderated—meaning we'll review and manually approve any comment before it gets posted to the website.
Please log in or create an account

Cellars Wine Club

90+ Point Wine Club