Sunset Wine Club Review
In this review · What is the Sunset Wine Club? · How it works · Sunset Wine Review · Who Should Join? · Pros & Cons · Gift Review
What is The Sunset Wine Club?
The Sunset Wine Club is the latest incarnation of a wine subscription backed by Sunset Magazine. Each shipment contains an exploration of some of the West Coast’s best small- to medium-sized wineries in California, Oregon, and Washington.
Managed by Wine Access, a quarterly subscription of six bottles costs $120 per box, and shipping is included. Cancel or skip a shipment any time.
Some backstory: many years ago Sunset Magazine had one of the best wine clubs on the market, because it featured interesting and affordable West Coast wines made by real wineries (as opposed to giant factory wineries who produce wine brands like Apothic and Ménage à Trois).
Based on the inaugural shipment, the spirit of this newest version of the club is the same, but the quality has crept upward while maintaining the same price.
How does the Sunset Club work?
Sunset Magazine, among other things, creates issues which provide in glorious detail what to see, and where to sleep, eat, and drink in regions all around the American West.
With the addition of their wine club, they’re able to bring more of that experience to their readers. No need to worry, you don’t to be a Sunset Magazine subscriber to get joy from the wine club.
Since Sunset Magazine is a publisher and not a wine seller, their wine club is a partnership between Sunset Magazine and Wine Access. Every three months you will receive six bottles of wine — $120, includes shipping but not sales tax — handpicked by Wine Access to pair with recipes from Sunset Magazine.
Even if you don't have a subscription to Sunset Magazine, you will be able to access the recipe pairings. Your club purchases will be managed on wineaccess.com.
Wine Access, helmed by Vanessa Conlin, a Master of Wine, and her team of amazingly qualified sommeliers and Master of Wine candidates, is one of my favorites! Vanessa offers exceptional guidance in the tasting videos provided for every bottle in each shipment.
Why this is a great team. Wine Access aims to highlight the stories, people, and quality of wines being produced in regions that are lesser known than regions with brand recognition like Napa Valley. Their site is all about wine, but much of the joy of wine is the pairing of specific wines with specific foods.
By partnering with Sunset Magazine, they can augment the experience of the wine they sell with top tier recipes for excellent at-home dining.
About this Sunset Wine Club Review
The Sunset Wine Club is a brand new wine subscription and so far I have reviewed one shipment of six wines. I am actively reviewing their service and most recently received a shipment in February of 2022. This review incorporates my Sunset Wine Club experiences and my experience with more than 100 other wine clubs.
Any wine subscription service is about more than just the wine and this review covers all aspects of the service. The key things I look for in a wine club are: How was the wine sourced? Is the wine selection personalized or curated? How often does it ship? How well does the company communicate about shipping and billing? Do they offer a satisfaction guarantee? Are the shipment sizes and wine selection flexible?
I also examine what kind of wine education they offer with their bottles and whether or not a service is set up for good gifting. These aspects are not core to a wine club being worthwhile, but they are important for many would-be members.
Sunset Magazine Club Wine Review
My Sunset Wine Club Wine Ratings
|Quality of Wine|
|Price of Wine|
Sunset Magazine is a legend in the west. For people new to the west coast and long time residents alike, we often turn to Sunset to learn how to incorporate more of the west’s stunning nature, food and wine culture, and trendy home design into our everyday lives. They earned this reputation by valuing the finer things in life and having impeccable taste.
The main reason to join this wine club is to get access to highly-recommended, approachable wines from the west, ostensibly suited to the tastes of the readers of Sunset Magazine.
Each bottle is introduced by a wine tasting video of Vanessa walking you through what you’re looking for — it’s like you’re wine tasting with a Master of Wine. You’ll also have access to detailed wine notes via Wine Access and recipe pairing suggestions from The Sunset Wine Club (accessible via a special page on Sunset.com).
The first shipment included these six compelling wines.
2018 Old Vines Field Blend from Three Wine Company in Contra Costa County
Blend: 77% Zinfandel, 11% Petite Sirah, 9% Carignane, 3% Alicante Bouschet
Retail price: $24 | Video Tasting Notes | Wine Access Write-up
I liked this. I drink a lot of Zinfandel and other California "red blends" (not the sweet ones) and what I especially like about this field blend — a type of blend I have a soft spot for — is that it embodies all of the best qualities of those grapes — a bit of spice, a bit of oak, some red fruit, some black fruit, a touch of smokiness… without being a punch in the mouth. The tannins are soft and approachable, with just a fine grit to coat the tongue.
2019 Westmount Pinot Noir
100% Pinot Noir from Willamette Valley, Oregon
Retail price: $25
Video Tasting Notes | Wine Access Write-up
Surprisingly exceptional value. I love Pinot Noir and have had more than my fair share of gems from Sta. Rita Hills. Generally I very much like Willamette Valley Pinot, too, with a preference for Yamhill-Carlton and, like in California, anything made with my favorite clones (115, 667 and 777, in case you’re wondering).
What I love more than anything else is a round, juicy, red fruit Pinot with smooth tannins and a long finish. These are things I don’t find enough of in most of Willamette’s Pinot Noir, and rarely find in a Pinot that costs less than $45. I stand corrected. This Westmount blew me away for value and it is a beautiful fruit-forward Pinot Noir that everyone should try.
2018 Courtney Benham Cabernet Sauvignon
100% Cabernet Sauvignon from Napa Valley
Retail price: $20
Video Tasting Notes | Wine Access Write-up
A curiously affordable wine with a serious pedigree, we brought this one to a party. I’m not personally much of a Cab drinker, so it wasn't my favorite, but it if you are into Cabernet, it had all the hallmarks of a classic Napa Cab — blackberry, cassis, and pretty smooth tannins for a young wine.
While everyone else drank this outstanding value, I sipped on another partygoer’s selection — an organic Nebbiolo from Langhe DOC in Italy that was tart and fruity. Everyone walked away happy.
2020 DeLille Cellars Chaleur Blanc
72% Sauvignon Blanc, 28% Sémillon from Columbia Valley, Washington
Retail price: $38 | Video Tasting Notes | Wine Access Write-up
I liked this. I haven’t had many traditional White Bordeaux Blends, but what I liked was that the Semillon added a bit of a honeyed, bitterish note to counteract the Sauv Blanc’s acidic fruitiness. It almost reminded me of a brighter Viognier or a Viognier/Roussanne blend.
As I find with most Washington wines, it’s more subtle than a California version of the same blend would (usually) be. I often think of Washington as a wine love child of California and France — more structure and ripeness than France, but less than California.
2019 Stolpman Vineyards Para Maria de las Tecolotes Syrah
80% Syrah, 20% Petit Verdot from Ballard Canyon, Santa Barbara County
Retail price: $22 | | Video Tasting Notes | Wine Access Write-up
I’ve been a wine club member at Stolpman Vineyards for over 10 years. I have nothing bad to say about Stolpman, and nothing but praise for the backstory on how Para Maria came be to — the literal fruit of a winery who puts its employees at the forefront of everything it does. Maria is the vineyard manager’s wife (and he’s not *just* the vineyard manager, he also made this wine).
I skipped tasting this wine for now, knowing from experience it will benefit from some time in the cellar — Stolpman’s Syrahs are exuberant and grippy when young, but smooth as silk and well-integrated with 5+ years on them. The 20% Petit Verdot is all the more reason to wait — the chewy structure it adds now will help it mature exceptionally.
Who should (and shouldn’t) join The Sunset Wine Club?
My Wine Access
While you certainly can join this club for the great wines at a great value, the wine education you’ll get by watching the videos and learning about wine in this way is what sets this club apart. In my opinion, the educational component is as valuable as what you’re paying for in the wine itself.
In general, the biggest reason to join a wine club is that you’re not required to do your own research to find great wine to drink at a great price. For people with the time, inclination, and knowledge, maybe that research is a fun undertaking. For most of us, having a trusted source of regular wine deliveries is a useful life hack.
This wine subscription is perfect for:
- Wine lovers looking to branch out from more easily found wines
- Folks who prefer fruit-forward, complex wines (what the US west coast is known for)
- Wine lovers on a budget (you’re drinking way above your spend, which is downright affordable)
Avoid this club if it’s your only one and:
- You want to try wines from around the world
- You want sparkling or sweet wines
- You want an even more premium experience. Try one of these other Wine Access gems instead.
Pros & Cons of The Sunset Wine Club
It’s a deal. The average cost per bottle in the subscription is $20 ($120 for six bottles, shipping included), but many of the wines in the box retail for well over $20. What’s interesting is that they don’t oversell the discounts, but I’m here to tell you you’re getting great value with this membership. For six easy-drinking, West Coast wines, you can’t find a better wine club than this one.
Each selection offers something special.
- The Three Wine Company red is made from both old vines and field blends — both increasingly rare in California
- The Courtney Benham Cab is made from grapes whose sources are protected by an NDA in Stags Leap, Rutherford, and Coombsville (all premium Napa regions)
- The DeLille Cellars is a classic white Bordeaux blend, but made in Washington
- The Westmount is a classic Willamette Valley Pinot Noir at a great price
- Same for the Sonoma Bench Chardonnay
- And the backstory on Stolpman’s Para Maria is worth checking into
The recipes. When I first reviewed the Michelin Guide Wine Club (another Wine Access subscription), I noted that there was a missed opportunity for the chefs at those Michelin-starred restaurants to provide paired recipes for those amazing wines. Special bottles deserve special meals and enthusiastic home chefs might go for complex recipes for date night at home.
With The Sunset Club we get the pairings! I am a home cook, but I'm a practical one. I found the recipes to be too complex for weeknight / $20 wines (the wines can stand up to them, but it’s a lot of effort for the cook). If you're more adventurous of a cook than I am you might enjoy them, too.
One example: Deep-fried Pork Belly in Adobo Sauce to pair with the Three Wine Company Field Blend. While many home cooks (myself included) don’t feel comfortable deep frying things at home and possibly don’t know where to buy skin-on Pork Belly near them, the recipes at Sunset are a big reason people subscribe.
Additional Discounts. Get 10% off all non-club purchases at Wine Access.
We get excellent information about the wines from the Wine Access side of the partnership, and Sunset brings the food side of the equation, but I am not really a fan of how Sunset talks about the club wines in their magazine.
While the descriptions of the wines on the individual recipes are excellent, they don’t describe why each wine pairs with each recipe. It makes it hard to pivot to a new recipe if you don’t like the one they’ve chosen. If you find yourself in this situation, I recommend the excellent food and wine pairing site, VinYang.com.
Is Sunset Wine Club a good gift?
At this time the Sunset Wine Club is not set up for gift memberships. If you want to give this as a gift you’ll instead need to sign up and make the payments until you decide it’s time to cancel.