Find Wine of the Month Clubs by Satisfaction Guarantee

When comparing wine club subscriptions, Satisfaction Guarantee is something you should look closely at


When was the last time you bought a bottle of wine you didn't like, and could return it for a replacement from the store where you purchased it? Probably the 12th of Never. A big perk of joining a wine club is the satisfaction guarantee. Each wine club who offers a guarantee approaches it a little differently. We've investigated each satisfaction guarantee to assess how good the guarantee really is and ranked each club accordingly.

Please note: This Satisfaction Guarantee rating is our rating of the wine club's Satisfaction Guarantee, not our own guarantee that you'll be satisfied with this wine subscription.

Please note: if you join or give a wine club after clicking our links we might earn a commission.


Filtered with your selected preferences


























  $20   $220
  $10   $100

Aged Cabernet Series

All-Around Rating:

Exclusive Deal For You Save 50% on your first shipment. Until Dec 31. Use code WCRHALF at checkout.


For Gifts Save 10% on all gifts at The California Wine Club. Until Dec 16. Use code QUALITY10 at checkout.


For Gifts Give a wine club gift of 3 months or longer and get free shipping — Save up to $168. Until Jan 2. Click for This Deal.


For You & For Gifts Save 10% on The Aged Cabernet Series for yourself or as a gift. Until Dec 16. Use code QUALITY10 at checkout.

Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: This wine club is perfect for Cabernet lovers who lack the patience to cellar red wines and those who want to explore aged wine with a Satisfaction Guarantee. Each shipment contains two bottles of perfectly-cellared, mostly Napa, California Cabernet Sauvignon that's ready to drink now.

What We Love: We like that they bring you a variety of aged Cabernet Sauvignon, at different levels of quality from exceptional to rarified. Each shipment explores the different wine regions of Napa Valley and Sonoma County, like Oakville, Alexander Valley, Atlas Peak, Howell Mountain, and Spring Mountain District. We also love that you can buy Cabernet online in their store.

Could Be Better: As a general rule, we think The California Wine Club has little they can do to improve. Whether you're buying for yourself or as a gift, they've really done a lot to create a wine club worth joining.

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

Case Club

All-Around Rating:

For Gifts Save 10% on The Case Club. Until Dec 16. Use code QUALITY10 at checkout.

Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: Among all of the case clubs (12 bottles, typically shipped quarterly), this California wine club offering selections from boutique wineries is one of the two best deals. The other club delivers 90+ point wine from around the world.

What We Love: We asked The California Wine Club for a case club deal and they made one! And now you get to save a TON of money on their already affordable Premier Series wines.

Could Be Better: Normally we'd ask for a deal for this club, but it's already priced as low as it can go, so it's perfect as is!

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

WINC Wine Club

by WINC
All-Around Rating:

Exclusive Deal For You Join today and save $25 on your first Winc box. Free shipping on orders of 4 or more bottles. Click for This Deal.


Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: Winc set out to change the wine industry by finding new ways to get better value to wine drinkers in the under $15 range, and boy have they ever. By delivering unprecedented value at $13 a bottle and personalized selections geared for every palate, Winc is a standout wine of the month club. If you're ready for more sophisticated wines, you can upgrade to Winc Select. Either way, you can save even more money by participating in their myriad rewards programs.

What We Love: We love how they go above and beyond to reward loyal customers with substantial savings and invitations to a premium level program. No other wine club offers this level of loyalty rewards, or this much fun! Also, as time has passed under wine director Ryan Zotovich, the selection of premium wines has both grown in selection and quality.

Could Be Better: Winc works so hard to make their service great that it's hard for us to think of something they should do to make it even better.

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

90+ Wine Club

All-Around Rating:

Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: Among all of the case clubs (12 bottles, typically shipped quarterly), this 90+ International wine club is among the best two deals. The other focuses only on California wine, but this one takes you on a journey around the world. Enjoy eclectic wines at the best prices you'll find.

What We Love: It's so easy to get into a wine rut and stick with what you know. Wired For Wine ® helps you break out of that rut in a low-cost, satisfaction guaranteed way so you can find new wines to love. Also, when compared with similarly-priced case clubs, this one stands out for wine quality in a big way.

Could Be Better: Normally we'd ask for a deal for this club, but it's already priced as low as it can go, so it's nearly perfect as is! We'd love to see a little bit of customization available and also monthly clubs for people who drink more than a bottle a week.

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

Premier Wine Club

All-Around Rating:

For You & For Gifts Save 10% on The Premier Series for yourself or as a gift. Until Dec 16. Use code QUALITY10 at checkout.


Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: This wine subscription focuses on high-quality and value-priced wines from small family wineries in California, and is perfect to give as a gift or to join yourself. Even though California wine is legendary, most of us can't afford legendary wine prices. The California Wine Club's "Love it" Guarantee means you'll love your wine or they'll send you something else at no additional cost.

What We Love: The California Wine Club appears on the most lists of best wine clubs on our website because they overdeliver on value, customer service, and quality. The Premier Series is their biggest wine club and is the perfect gift for a California wine lover. If you join for yourself, you'll also enjoy wine credits, concierge service for wine tasting trips to California, and more perks of membership. The California Wine Club now regularly offers introductory discounts, and that makes this wine club a better value while still delivering fantastic quality.

Could Be Better: Our only complaints about the Premier Series are twofold. First, if you order red wine only or white wine only, you'll get two of the same wine in your shipment. Second, they offer a 4-bottle version of the wine club (with free shipping), but you have to call to upgrade and we wish they would just offer it on the website when you sign up.

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

Red Wine Club

All-Around Rating:

Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: The Plonk red wine club has always been among our favorites because of the proprietor's preference for quirky but delectable wines. Etty Lewensztain sources interesting wines made from grapes and regions you've never heard of (and some you have). Whether you choose four or twelve bottles you'll be glad you picked Plonk.

What We Love: Lately we've come to think of Plonk as the "Somm club" that isn't run by a sommelier. With a focus on wines under $30 that will delight any curious wine drinker, we think the value is top notch. Also, unlike most wine clubs, if you're thinking of going red-only or white-only, you'll actually get four different selections (three of each if you upgrade to 12 bottles).

Could Be Better: When it comes to Plonk we have little to ask for in the improvement department. Because the wines are so great, we'd really like to see a more giftworthy version of the subscription which includes gift wrap and maybe even store credits so they can order more of their favorites.

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

International Selections

All-Around Rating:

Exclusive Deal For You Save 50% on your first shipment. Until Dec 31. Use code WCRHALF at checkout.


For Gifts Give a wine club gift of 3 months or longer and get free shipping — Save up to $168. Until Jan 2. Click for This Deal.


For You & For Gifts Save 10% on The International Series for yourself or as a gift. Until Dec 16. Use code QUALITY10 at checkout.

Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: Using the same methods of wine selection for more than 25 years, The California Wine Club expanded their vision to include an International wine club, too. Get an in-depth look at new-to-you wine regions around the world with all of the perks of being a member of The California Wine Club.

What We Love: As hard as it is to find boutique wines produced in the United States, it's even harder to find these tiny gems overseas.The fine selections we received were an eclectic pair of wines from Becker Vineyards in Germany; a Pinot Noir and a Pinot Gris. There is much to love about The California Wine Club, but we especially love their devotion to their members. We also like that it's a family business supporting family wineries.

Could Be Better: As a general rule, we think The California Wine Club has little they can do to improve. Whether you're buying for yourself or as a gift, they've really done a lot to create a wine club worth joining.

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

Pacific Northwest Club

All-Around Rating:

Exclusive Deal For You Save 50% on your first shipment. Until Dec 31. Use code WCRHALF at checkout.


For Gifts Give a wine club gift of 3 months or longer and get free shipping — Save up to $168. Until Jan 2. Click for This Deal.


For You & For Gifts Save 10% on The Pacific Northwest Series for yourself or as a gift. Until Dec 16. Use code QUALITY10 at checkout.

Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: This wine club features wines from Oregon and Washington — two award-winning wine regions drawing the attention of those in the know. Using the same methods and ideas of wine selection as they've used for years in California, The California Wine Club has translated their vision to an Pacific Northwest region. Get an in-depth look at these Burgundian and Bordeaux-style regions with all of the perks of being a member of The California Wine Club.

What We Love: The California Wine Club has an excellent reputation and they've been in business a long time. We like that it's a family business supporting family wineries.

Could Be Better: We have very little we feel The California Wine Club could do to improve. The prices sometimes feel a bit high, but when you factor in all of the benefits of membership, including a satisfaction guarantee, we still feel like you get what you pay for here.

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

The Limited Series

All-Around Rating:

Exclusive Deal For Gifts Save 10% on any wine of the month club gift. Use code BESTWINE at checkout or Click for This Deal.

Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: These are the highest level wines you can get in a membership from The Original Wine of the Month Club ™, generally well-made wines from well-known areas. At $25-30 a bottle, it's competitive with several other wine clubs on price, but the wines are little more "traditional" and not discovery oriented.

What We Love: Paul Kalemkiarian, second generation proprietor at Wine of the Month Club ™ goes out of his way to source interesting wines, and in this price point that can be a challenge, particularly in finding California wines. So he leans on an International selection to bring you better value in this price range.

Could Be Better: This is our favorite wine subscription from Wine of the Month Club, but we think the marketing text on their website is a little overhyped. Expect very good wines for these prices, but "Special Occasion" seems too generous of a description.

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club

Bordeaux Wine Club

All-Around Rating:

Exclusive Deal For Gifts Save 10% on any wine of the month club gift. Use code BESTWINE at checkout or Click for This Deal.

Satisfaction Guarantee Rating:

Our rating of the company's stated guarantee, not our guarantee of your satisfaction

Overview: Bordeaux is famous for huge price tags on their Premier Cru wines, but Bordeaux is a big region and there are many producers of less-expensive Bordeaux wines. This club focuses on these growers and ships every other month.

What We Love: Who doesn't love getting world-class Bordeaux wine at bargain prices? While Bordeaux often fetches upwards of $80 a bottle, these other Bordeaux wines delight at just $25 a bottle.

Could Be Better: We'd love to see this club delivered monthly and in larger quantities... two bottle just doesn't seem like enough! It is the perfect amount for a wine club gift, though...

Read Our ReviewGo Directly to the Wine Club